Due to a random set of circumstances, I ended up at the movie theater watching
Law-Abiding Citizen yesterday. I really don't recommend this movie.
SPOILERS1) The entire premise of the movie is both a) ridiculous (home invasions/burglaries are extremely unlikely to end with the burglars killing/raping everyone in the house) and b) unmotivated - I'm sorry, but if you're going to make one of your burglars an apparent psychopath, you need to develop that, not just take it for granted that half of all burglars are psychopaths.
2) Torture porn scene. That alone should be enough to discredit the film.
3) Targeted, portable EMP, that apparently doesn't knock out all electronics, just the convenient ones. Radios still work. No. Just...no. Unless your movie has aliens or is supposed to be set in the future. And the radios still have to die. *headdesk*
4) I admit I was happy that the Citizen - he can't really be called the protagonist, even though the movie is nominally about him and his struggle to rationalize his sociopathy - didn't come off as a sympathetic character. I was disappointed in that I got the sense that this was more due to the crappy characterization of the entire film, rather than actual intent on the writers' part. I think he was actually
supposed to be mildly understandable, but the egregious lengths to which they took his revenge left him nothing but a monster.
5) Excuse me, but if you have a prisoner IN JAIL who is committing MASS MURDER OF GOVERNMENT WORKERS? Then the Philadelphia DA and his detective buddy are not going to be the ones working this damn case. The fucking FBI would be on this like white on rice.
6) There were, by my count, approximately 13 people killed. Five of them were faceless extras. One was the nameless cellmate pawn. Two of them were the original burglar/bad guys. One was mentor-guy to the DA/protag. The remaining four were the wife and daughter of the Citizen, the mentee of the DA, and the strict female judge who apparently tries every case in Philly.
Of the seven characters our male leads have any indicated relationship to, two are bad guys, five are good. Of the five good, all of whom die (fairly cheaply) in service to the plot/motivations of the main characters, four are women/girls.
OMGEE women and children are dying! Look at how heinous these deaths are! It sure makes his actions understandable!!!!111!1!
No, actually. The bad guy who killed the wife and daughter was awful, but he was also so unrealistic as to be laughable. A caricature of villany. Your good guy is supposed to be understandable, but not only does he kill multiple innocents for the crime of working for the EBIL justice system, his revenges against the original burglars are so out of proportion as to be unbelievably sickening - not for his committing the acts, but for the writers thinking that they would be relatable. I hope I never meet those people.
So. Yeah. The movie was pretty shitty. Which I expected. Cmon. Die Hard was more realistic than this movie. ALAN RICKMAN.